Common questions · Faith & observance
The sources that record the birth inside the Kaaba record the exclusivity in the same breath: no one before him and no one after him. Al-Alusi says the merit was never established for anyone else. One report names Hakim ibn Hizam, but it rests on a single line of transmission, while the report about Ali is called mutawatir.
Faith & observanceReviewed 2026-11
The authorities who report the birth almost always add the exclusivity to it — that no one was born in the House before him and no one after. Al-Alusi states plainly that such a merit was never established for anyone else, and that is why the report reads as a distinction of Ali rather than a curiosity about the building.
One report complicates the picture: some Sunni narrations name Hakim ibn Hizam, a nephew of Khadijah, as having been born inside the Kaaba. It is not treated as equal weight. The birth of Ali is carried by multiple chains and called mutawatir by al-Hakim al-Nishapuri; the report about Hakim ibn Hizam hangs on a single transmission, and the scholars quoted above still state the exclusivity for Ali.
So what a reader finds in both schools' books is the statement about Ali — and the exclusivity is part of why the date carries the weight it does. See 13 Rajab in the sacred calendar for when it falls this year.
al-Alusi, Sharh al-Kharidah al-Ghaybiyyah; al-Hakim al-Nishapuri, al-Mustadrak; Shah Waliullah al-Dihlawi, Izalat al-Khifa.