Common questions · Faith & observance
Yes. Under the Umayyads and the early Abbasids armed checkpoints stood on the roads to Karbala, and pilgrims risked imprisonment and death. Imam al-Sadiq (a) kept urging the visit through it and promised that fear borne for the ziyarah would itself be answered — a world away from today's millions at Arbaeen.
Faith & observanceReviewed 2026-11
For most of the first two centuries the ziyarah was a journey made against the state. The Umayyads placed garrisons and checkpoints (masalih) on the road to Karbala to stop pilgrims reaching the grave, and the early Abbasids continued the practice; visitors were arrested, and some were killed. Ibn Bakr al-Arjani described the fear in a letter to Imam al-Sadiq (a):
إني أنزل الأرّجان وقلبي ينازعني إلى قبر أبيك، فإذا خرجت فقلبي وجِل مشفق حتى أرجع خوفاً من السلطان والسعاة وأصحاب المسالح
I stay at al-Arjan and my heart pulls me to your father's grave, but when I set out my heart trembles until I return, for fear of the ruler, his agents and the men of the checkpoints. The Imam's answer did not tell him to be careful — it told him what the fear itself buys: whoever fears for our sake, God will shade him under His Throne, and the one who bears it will be safe on the day when others are terrified.
The Imam knew the road himself: in the early Abbasid period he came to Iraq more than once, stayed at al-Hira near Kufa and taught in the Kufa mosque, and visited the grave on those journeys — which is how his bequests describe the shrine so precisely, down to the eastern gate and the enclosure wall. He told his companions plainly not to abandon the visit:
يا معاوية لا تدع زيارة قبر الحسين خلوفاً، فإن من تركه رأى من الحسرة ما يتمنى أن قبره كان عنده
O Mu'awiya, do not leave the ziyarah of the grave of Husayn out of fear, for whoever abandons it will see a regret that will make him wish the grave had been beside him.
The narrations add that the shrine is guarded and the visitors prayed for: the angels were charged with guarding the grave of Husayn and seeking forgiveness for those who come to it, and the Imam said that more pray for his visitors in heaven than on earth.
The contrast with the present is the point of remembering it. The pilgrimage the state once tried to stop is now the largest annual gathering on earth — Arbaeen alone draws tens of millions to the same road — and the practical question today is not whether you may go but how to go safely.
Kamil al-Ziyarat (Ibn Qulawayh), pp. 222, 230, 243–247; Ahmad al-Asadi, "al-Ha'ir al-Husayni…" (the historical survey of the visits and the roads).