Common questions · Faith & observance

Why are the shrines of Imam Husayn and Abbas separate?

Al-Abbas (a) was buried away from the Imam's grave, and the Ha'ir — the enclosure drawn around Imam Husayn's tomb and the martyrs buried with him — never took his grave inside it. The ground between the two shrines became the covered street known as bayn al-haramayn, walked by every pilgrim.

Faith & observanceReviewed 2026-11

The two shrines face each other a few minutes' walk apart in the centre of Karbala, across the covered street called bayn al-haramayn, "between the two sanctuaries". They are separate buildings because the graves were never in one place: al-Abbas (a) was killed at the canal while fetching water for the camp, and he was buried where he fell, at the edge of the sacred ground rather than at its centre.

The boundary is explicit in the sources. The Ha'ir is defined as the wall enclosing the grave of Imam Husayn and those martyred with him at Karbala —

الحائر الحسيني: مصطلح يطلق على السور الذي يحيط بقبر الإمام الحسين وقبور الذين استشهدوا معه في واقعة كربلاء المقدسة، ما عدا قبر أخيه أبي الفضل العباس بن علي فإنه خارج عن حدود ذلك السور

— that is, the enclosure of the Imam and the martyrs, "except the grave of his brother Abu al-Fadl al-Abbas, which lies outside that wall." The ziyarah of al-Abbas narrated from Abu Hamza al-Thumali says the same thing from the other side:

إذا أردت زيارة قبر العباس بن علي وهو على شاطئ الفرات بحذاء الحائر فقف على باب السقيفة

When you wish to visit the grave of al-Abbas ibn Ali — it lies on the bank of the Euphrates, alongside the Ha'ir — stand at the gate of the portico. The "Euphrates" there is the Alqami canal beside the shrine, the same water the bequests name for the ghusl.

So the two visits were separate from the beginning, and they remain separate: pilgrims greet the Imam at his zarih, cross bayn al-haramayn, and greet al-Abbas at his, with the etiquette and ziyarah of each visit said on its own. The shrine of the Imam and the shrine of al-Abbas each have a site guide on this site.

Source

Kamil al-Ziyarat (Ibn Qulawayh), the ziyarah of al-Abbas (a) narrated from Abu Hamza al-Thumali; Ahmad al-Asadi, "al-Ha'ir al-Husayni…" (the enclosure and its boundary).

Related

Al-Abbas Shrine — the site guide

All common questions